Skip to main content

Background article

Building the ARA workflow Ableton Live never got

Why I stopped waiting for ARA in Ableton Live and built ALIGN and EDIT myself: what I wanted, what I wasn't sure was possible, and what testers changed.

Building the ARA workflow Ableton Live never got. The article title on the null.audio title card.

I'm a producer first. Ableton Live is where I write, arrange and feel at home. But for years, every time a song got to the vocals, I left it. I opened Cubase, because Cubase supports ARA and Live doesn't, and ARA is what makes Melodyne and VocAlign feel like part of the DAW instead of something you feed audio into.

With every Live update I hoped ARA would be in the release notes. It never was. So at some point I stopped waiting and built the workflow I wanted myself.

What I wanted, in one sentence

Click a clip in the Arrangement, edit it in Melodyne or align it in VocAlign, hear it in the song, and put it back. No playing the part in first. No printing my vocal chain into the audio. No moving clips to a clean track just to bounce them.

Everything in null.audio comes back to that sentence.

ALIGN came first

Aligning doubles was the bigger pain for me, so I started there. Stacking vocals means aligning the same chorus four, six, eight times, and in Live each of those meant a capture pass in real time. ALIGN opens VocAlign with the lead and every double already in it, and puts each aligned double back on its own track. That turned an evening of capture passes into a few presses.

EDIT was the part I wasn't sure about

Opening a clip in Melodyne was one thing. Hearing the edit in the song while I make it, through the vocal chain on the track, in time with Live, was something else. That's what makes editing in Cubase feel natural, and it's what Live has no way to do with these plug-ins.

I didn't know if I could get that to work reliably. So before I promised EDIT to anyone, I tested it on its own, separately from ALIGN, with a clear rule: if it isn't solid, EDIT doesn't ship. It took the longest of anything in the project, and it's the part I'm proudest of. When I first tuned a note and heard it change in the mix, through my own compressor and de-esser, I knew it would be a product.

The rules I set myself

Building something that changes audio in someone else's song comes with responsibility. A few rules were fixed from the start, and every feature had to follow them:

  • Your original is never touched until you say so. Nothing changes in Live until you press Apply, and Revert always gets the original back.
  • Your vocal chain stays yours. Your effects stay on the track as plug-ins, never printed into the audio.
  • Stay in Live. You work in the Arrangement, with your clips where they are. The panels sit beside Live, and every button can be mapped to a key or a MIDI control.
  • Use the plug-ins you already own. null.audio doesn't replace Melodyne or VocAlign. It makes them work in Live.

Testing everything I claim

The website only says something works if I've tested it. That meant every editor EDIT supports: Melodyne, SpectraLayers, RePitch, Vovious and VoiceAssist. Every version of VocAlign ALIGN supports, Pro and Standard. And all of it on macOS and on Windows, on real setups, with real songs. What isn't tested is marked that way on the support page.

That's slow, and it's the reason null.audio launched with a short list instead of a long one.

What people taught me

When 1.0 came out, I watched people use it. Two things stood out. The panels were where people hesitated, because they didn't always show what to do next. And EDIT opened one clip at a time, while a real vocal is a comped verse with doubles on other tracks.

null.audio 1.1 fixes both. The panels now show the step you're on and one button for what comes next, and EDIT opens a whole verse with its doubles in one Melodyne session. Neither was my idea alone. They came from people who wrote to me and from watching them work.

What's next

ALIGN now has a first version of my own alignment engine, called Built-in. It lines up Dubs inside null.audio with no plug-in. In 1.1 it's a beta and doesn't line up as well as VocAlign yet, so that's one thing I'm working on next. The other is my own vocal editor in EDIT, for tuning without Melodyne or another plug-in. The roadmap shows where both stand.

If something in your vocal workflow still makes you leave Live, I want to hear it: contact@null.audio. Most of what's in 1.1 started as an email like that.

null.audio ALIGN and null.audio EDIT bring vocal alignment and ARA editing into Live.