Compare
Melodyne in Ableton Live: Transfer or EDIT
Melodyne's Transfer pass or null.audio EDIT in Ableton Live: what each takes, what you hear while you edit, and when Transfer is the better choice.
Compare
Each page puts the ways to do one job next to each other: what it takes, what you hear while you work, and when the other route is the better one.
I make null.audio, and two of these pages put my own products next to the routes you already have. What they say about other products comes from their makers' own pages, linked under Sources. For the background, start with ARA in Ableton Live.
Compare
Melodyne's Transfer pass or null.audio EDIT in Ableton Live: what each takes, what you hear while you edit, and when Transfer is the better choice.
Compare
VocAlign's realtime capture or null.audio ALIGN in Ableton Live: what each takes for one double or a stack of eight, and when capture is the better choice.
Compare
Tuning and aligning vocals in Ableton Live, Cubase or Studio One (now Fender Studio Pro): what ARA changes, and when switching DAWs is the better answer.
Compare
Three ARA vocal editors in Ableton Live: what each one edits, how each works in Live with and without EDIT, and which fits which vocal job.